Eat Hamptons
Menu

Seafood in the Hamptons

5 seafood listings, from a walk-in fish market to a dock owned by six fishermen, and most of them take no reservations.

Last checked October 28, 2026. Next scheduled checks: May and October.

Seafood is the group where season and booking rules diverge most. The Canal Cafe, Bostwick's and Out of the Blue take no reservations. Inlet Seafood is walk-in only, with a price-fixe option for parties of eight or more. Duryea's has posted a season closing.

Of the five, only the two listed as waterfront by their own sites name the water: the Canal Cafe on the Shinnecock Canal and Inlet on Block Island Sound. See the waterfront page for the full list.

Seafood listings

  • Bostwick's Chowder House
    East Hampton · Seafood

    Casual local seafood, Thursday to Sunday from 11:30 am, patio and takeout, no reservations.

    Thursday to Sunday, from 11:30 am

  • Duryea's Montauk
    Montauk · Seafood

    Lobster deck whose own page lists a season closing of 9/19. Closed for now.

    Closed in winter. Closed for the season: its page lists "Season Closing 9/19"

  • Inlet Seafood
    Montauk · Seafood, Japanese

    Owned by six local fishermen on Block Island Sound. Walk in only; posts no hours.

    Not posted on its site; the site points to Instagram @inletseafoodmtk

  • Out of the Blue Seafood
    Hampton Bays · Seafood

    Fish market and restaurant in Hampton Bays, 10 am to 8 pm daily, smoking seafood on site.

    Every day, 10 am to 8 pm

  • The Canal Cafe
    Hampton Bays · Seafood · $$

    Deck over the Shinnecock Canal. Lobster roll $34 or $44. Closed Monday and Tuesday; no reservations.

    Wednesday to Saturday, 12 pm to 9 pm

Sources