What to know before you go
Out of the Blue combines a seafood market and a restaurant at 252 East Montauk Highway in Hampton Bays. Its site says: "No reservations needed. Just walk in, grab a table." It lists every day, 10 am to 8 pm, from early lunch through dinner.
The market sells fresh fish and local oysters. Its page also lists clams and mussels, plus lobster. It says it smokes seafood on site, naming tuna, salmon and whitefish. It also sells gift cards and takes online orders.
The phone numbers listed are 631-728-3474 and 631-728-FISH.
Staying near Out of the Blue Seafood? See current Hampton Bays rentals on Hamptons Key, or read the full Hampton Bays restaurant guide.
Common questions
Is Out of the Blue Seafood open in winter?
Out of the Blue Seafood has not announced a winter schedule. The site says it is open every day and gives no closing date. Checked October 28, 2026.
What are Out of the Blue Seafood's hours?
As posted on its website on October 28, 2026: Every day, 10 am to 8 pm.
Does Out of the Blue Seafood take reservations?
No reservations needed: walk in, grab a table.
Plan around it
Getting to Hampton Bays: Hamptons Commute. Beaches nearby: Hamptons Beach Day.
Sources
Every fact on this page comes from the sources below. Hours, menus and prices change: confirm with Out of the Blue Seafood before you go.
- Out of the Blue Seafood: market and restaurant Checked October 28, 2026.
- Out of the Blue Seafood: home page Checked October 28, 2026.