What to know before you go
Nick & Toni's says it opened in 1988 and describes its dining rooms as a Tuscan farmhouse setting with a wood-burning oven, an extensive drink program and outsider art. It sits on North Main Street in East Hampton village.
The dinner menu posted on October 28, 2026 credits Balsam Farms for its kale, arugula and broccoli and Mattituck Farm for mushrooms, and lists local littleneck clams and local striped bass. Balsam Farms runs a farm stand in Amagansett.
Wood-fired 10-inch pizzas are listed for Sunday through Thursday only, excluding holidays. Takeout is available: order online, or call after 2:00 pm and pay by credit card. The site says outside dessert is not allowed.
Two rooms can each be reserved for up to 30 guests, and the whole restaurant for up to 80. That is a posted option for group dinners.
No pets are allowed on the property. Service animals as defined by the ADA are welcome.
Staying near Nick & Toni's? See current East Hampton rentals on Hamptons Key, or read the full East Hampton restaurant guide.
From the posted menu
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Wood-fired Margherita pizza, 10 inch (Sunday to Thursday) | $24 |
| House-made tagliatelle with duck ragù | $26 / $36 |
| Grilled local striped bass | $52 |
| Wood-grilled New York strip steak | $85 |
Common questions
Is Nick & Toni's open in winter?
Nick & Toni's has not announced a winter schedule. The site posts one set of current hours and no closing date. Checked October 28, 2026.
What are Nick & Toni's' hours?
As posted on its website on October 28, 2026: Wednesday to Monday, from 5:30 pm. Closed Tuesday.
Does Nick & Toni's take reservations?
Yes, through Resy. The restaurant asks that requests not be sent by email.
Plan around it
Getting to East Hampton: Hamptons Commute. Beaches nearby: Hamptons Beach Day.
Sources
Every fact on this page comes from the sources below. Hours, menus and prices change: confirm with Nick & Toni's before you go.
- Nick & Toni's: home page with hours, menu and policies Checked October 28, 2026.